You can't go back
At Smith Elementary, my best friend was Geoff Otto, at least for the first few years. We met because my mom had daycare in our home and both of his parents worked. After school we would walk or ride the mile between school and my house and we would play until it was time for him to go. Through the summer he would come over in the morning and we would spend the heat of the day burning things with the magnifying glasses he got from a store near his home.
The first time I went over to his house, I realized he didn't live like I did. His house was not huge, but it was big and well kept. Quiet. The exterior was brick with an unusual peak, the grass was well kept and smooth, the single tree provided shade, but it didn't seem to have dropped any leaves. The reddish colored front door opened up into a small entryway and then you were in a home with kept wood floors and beautiful rugs. We didn't really spend anytime in the living room. In the office, with a desk and bookshelves full of engineering and thick schoolbooks, there was a computer, which had games we took turns playing. Upstairs his room, which had walls angled like the peak I had seen outside, had a milk crate with Advanced Dungeons and Dragons books and his own Atari. His house was heaven to me.
In a few months, I had an opportunity to stay the night. Can you imagine a whole night full of games and wonder? I, of course, wanted to go and my parents agreed. This was my first sleep over at a friends house. The day went great, but as darkness settled in, my mind started to wonder home. By bedtime, I actually started crying and my parents had to come to pick me up.
This did not ruin our friendship. He didn't tease me or tell anyone I had broken down. Additionally, he invited me over again, which went much better. No more tears.
I don't exactly remember how all of this unfolded, but Geoff no longer needed to come to our house to be watched and in fifth grade he had been moved into private school. We met a couple times after that, but it wasn't the same. The schedule didn't work for us, we had gone in different directions. There was no moment, it just faded away.
In eighth or ninth grade, I got it into my head that I wanted to be friends with Geoff again. I think it was because I had my own Dungeons and Dragons group and it reminded me of him. Whatever it was, I tracked him down. With his last name and his street I looked him up in the phone book. I stilled my courage and called him. He wasn't there the first time and he didn't call me back. The second time I called him, he was there and we decided to get together on Saturday. He invited me to his house.
I was excited to go back to the house I had, had so much fun in. I could only imagine the games and things we could do. When my Mom dropped me off, I didn't even hesitate. The house was just as I remembered, Geoff looked different, taller, but I could still see him. We played games on his computer, which was new, but n the same place as the old one. It wasn't that fun. We went to his room, where he still had a game system, but he wasn't really that interested. We talked about the games we had and had played, but there was no connection. I told him of my D&D group, which was playing 2nd edition, he had the same books in the same milk crate. He hadn't played them since the days we used to flip through them.
My hope had a slow leak. Everywhere we turned, every activity we tried was like an attempt to catch our own ghosts. I didn't know then, what I know now. You can't go back. You can love the memory, even work hard to recreate it, but the truth is, you can't. We didn't have an awful time, we were cordial and tried to keep ourselves entertained, but when Mom picked me up, I think we both knew this was the end. I never called him again.